India’s New Intellectual Property Policy: A Critique
First published on The Dialog.
Last month the Modi government introduced a new policy on intellectual property rights (IPRs). It lays out the government’s approach to strengthen IPRs with a view to foster innovation and protect India’s traditional knowledge, and envisions “an India where knowledge is the main driver of development, and knowledge owned is transformed into knowledge shared.” (p.1)
Several commentaries on the policy have appeared over the past month. Some have been critical of its “maximalist” orientation arguing that India is at a stage of development where its domestic economic interests are not served by excessively strong IPR laws. Others have argued that the new policy has been drafted with the interest of multinational corporations in mind, rather than ordinary Indians. MNCs are generally in favor of stringent IPR laws because they stand to gain monopoly rents via patents, trademarks, and copyrights and stand to lose the more these are infringed by local businesses. Still others have noted that Indian IPR laws were changed recently under the UPA government and that there was no need for another comprehensive policy change so soon.
In this piece I want to use the policy document to raise some fundamental questions about intellectual property and its relevance for India. In the current climate, IPRs are often seen as the only way to ensure that creators of knowledge and culture receive returns for their creative efforts. Given the structure of India’s economy and the nature of knowledge production in it, what should be our approach to property rights in knowledge and culture? Can we lead the way in offering an alternative to privatisation? These issues remain un-debated even as policies continue to be drafted and implemented.
Knowledge and culture are what economists call “non-rival” and “non-excludable” goods. Om purnamadah purnamidam…as the Sanskrit shloka goes. Sharing does not reduce knowledge but adds to it. A common property or commons approach to knowledge has been the defining feature of our society, as the policy document acknowledges, noting that “monetisation of knowledge has never been the norm in India.” (p.8)
But private property rights in knowledge and culture are rapidly replacing open-access and common property regimes all over the world. International agreements such as TRIPS go a long way in ensuring this. Within such agreements, access to developed country markets for developing countries is often predicated on stringent domestic IPR laws. The policy document notes that the traditional Indian approach mentioned above, “while laudable and altruistic”,
…does not fit with the global regime of zealously protected IPRs. Hence, there is a need to propagate the value of transforming knowledge into IP assets. This requires a major paradigm shift of how knowledge is viewed and valued – not for what it is, but for what it can become. (p. 8)
The “major paradigm shift” referred to is the shift from treating knowledge and culture as common heritage and property to treating it as private property. Globalisation has brought with it an unprecedented level of experimentation with common property approaches to knowledge and culture. The FLOSS (Free/Libre Open Source Software) movement, peer-to-peer (P2P) movement, wikimedia commons and many similar movements across the world are changing our idea of knowledge and cultural production.
India’s knowledge and culture landscape is well-suited to a commons regime. Unlike countries like the US or EU members, a very large proportion of knowledge production and culture creation in India occurs outside the corporate sector. The so-called “informal sector” which employs 90% of our workforce is the site of this production. Whether it is farmers innovating new techniques, weavers and other artisans figuring out new ways of working with new designs and fabrics, food workers innovating new products, folk singers with new songs, or countless others, these knowledge and culture producers are untouched by an IPR regime.
This system, over centuries, has created a highly diverse and sophisticated ecology of knowledge and culture in food, music, textiles, and various household goods. In this sector, dissemination of knowledge and culture is rapid. A new product quickly spreads in the market by imitation. Thus, monopoly rents for innovation disappear quickly but competition serves as a motivator for innovation. The writers of the new policy certainly recognise this fact.
Eventual privatisation of the immense informal knowledge commons is the goal of the policy. The strongest defense offered for such an effort, in a poor country like India, is that it will enhance incomes in the informal sector (e.g. see this World Bank report). The argument goes that unlike the knowledge commons such as Wikipedia alluded to above that have been developed “on the side” by people who do not earn a living from this activity, informal knowledge commons are created and sustained by those whose livelihoods directly depend on them.
It is true that lack of formal property rights makes it easy for larger market actors, say in the corporate sector, to capitalise on knowledge produced in the informal sector. Generally we are used to thinking of piracy as the other way around; small, informal businesses producing knock-offs of large brands such as Nike shoes or Gucci bags. But piracy occurs the other way too; the most famous example being biopiracy. It is the appropriation of traditional knowledge particularly of medicinal plants, by large pharmaceutical companies.
Further, patent and trademark protected products are rapidly displacing informal products on which they are often based (for example countless varieties of bhujia, sweets etc). A small “innovation” on top of a local product by a large corporation with the resources to secure an IPR results in a trademarked product. The local product on which the trademarked product is based is forced out of the market by economics of aggressive pricing, and attractive packaging and marketing. The resulting destruction of local economies means the destruction of jobs (with women being hurt more than men) and communities. Thus on the face of it, the argument for strengthening IPRs for this knowledge is strong.
But millions of scattered innovators are not easily amenable to private IPRs. One way to get around this problem is to create community-based IPRs for the informal sector, e.g. Geographical Indications (GIs) which are IPRs that cover not an individual or a company but a community of producers, such as Banarasi Sari weavers or Moradabad metalworkers. Since 2005 India has created more than 400 GIs in diverse agricultural and artisanal products. A second way to safeguard informally produced knowledge from appropriation is the Traditional Knowledge Digital Library (TKDL). Here the strategy is to ensure that patent officials all over the world have access to “prior art” that they can use to evaluate if a particular product is new enough to deserve a patent or copyright. The new policy outlines the need for expanding the TKDL to include other fields besides Ayurveda, Yoga, Unani and Siddha, that it already covers.
Both these approaches are better suited to India’s knowledge ecology being community-oriented rather than private. But they are also severely limited when juxtaposed with the immense diversity of products and scale of innovation that occurs daily in the millions of micro, small, and medium enterprises in the unincorporated informal sector. It is not only a matter of “traditional knowledge” that matters to a few artisanal communities. Rather it is the livelihood basis of 90% of our workforce. Further, in a context where the informal sector is severely underserved in terms of infrastructure (such as electricity) and several reforms that aid production in this sector are overdue, banking on more stringent IPRs to enhance informal sector incomes is, to say the least, unrealistic and unwise.
Our challenge is to develop an intellectual property regime that can aid local economies in their fight for earning decent livelihoods based on their own knowledge and resisting corporate take-over, while developing a commons-based alternative to private property rights in knowledge and culture. This will not be easy since it means taking on powerful global vested interests in intellectual property. But the payoff will be very large both in terms of helping local economies and leading the way in treating knowledge and culture as a commons.
Crafting a robust Intellectual Property (IP) policy is paramount for any organization aiming to safeguard its innovations and creations. Consider lawsuit negligence in addressing IP concerns can leave businesses vulnerable to costly lawsuits and reputational damage.
This is a fascinating critique of India’s new intellectual property policy and how it affects the informal sector. The tension between private and community-based IPRs is clear, and it’s essential to find a balance that supports local economies without enabling corporate takeovers. As someone struggling with my own college work, I’ve realized how crucial it is to search for reliable resources. If you’re in a similar situation, I recommend to read https://edureviewer.com/tutoring/mysupergeek-review/ for academic help. Balancing innovation and protection in the informal sector is as challenging as managing schoolwork.
I’m in awe of this article, thank you for sharing it with us! Wish me luck as I take on the Certification FC0-U61 test answers exam!
What a beautiful article, I appreciate you sharing it with us! Thanks to the 700-250 latest soft simulations program, I secured a promotion and salary increase. It’s available for free now. Wishing you all quick promotions!
I’m truly thankful for your article, it really stood out. The NSE7_OTS-7.2 valid test dumps sheet content is truly great, and it’s free of charge.
Thank you for sharing this remarkable article, it truly impressed me. Free C_TFG61_2405 latest exam vce available to enhance your IT expertise. Good luck!
This article is a great source of inspiration, thank you! Sharing the free Cybersecurity-Architecture-and-Engineering valid test collection file resources with everyone. Good luck!
This article is truly worth reading, and I have learned a lot. Sharpen your IT skills and grab free CAST exam study guide. Wishing you success!
The content of the article is rich and logical, and it has given me many ideas. This DES-1415 valid test dumps free helped me get promoted and earn a pay raise. Now it’s free for everyone. Best wishes for your career advancements!
I’m really thankful for your article, it left a strong impression. The Latest ACSP test blueprint exam questions are your pathway to career advancement—now available for free!
KoreaDumps의 IBM C1000-138덤프로IBM C1000-138시험준비를 하면 시험패스는 간단한 일이라는걸 알게 될것입니다. IBM C1000-138덤프는 최근IBM C1000-138시험의 기출문제모음으로 되어있기에 적중율이 높습니다.시험에서 떨어지면 덤프비용 전액 환불해드리기에 우려없이 덤프를 주문하셔도 됩니다.
Clicking like instantly—this is fantastic. Don’t miss out on the Exam 1z0-071 consultant questions—free and essential for your promotion and salary increase!
Your article took my breath away, thank you for sharing! The OGBA-101 new study guide questions are crucial for your career progression—get them for free!
Your article was incredibly insightful, thank you! The SY0-701 practice questions exam helped me climb the career ladder and increase my salary, and today, I’m offering it to you for free!
This article has helped me understand many complex concepts, and I’ve gained a lot. Free AZ-700 exam overview test papers for everyone—promotions and salary raises await!
Thank you for your article; it truly broadened my horizons! Upgrade your IT expertise with free 200-301 reliable exam questions. Wishing you success!
I’m in awe of this article, thank you for sharing it. With New UiPath-ADPv1 exam questions and answers, you get access to valuable content at no cost, designed for your benefit.
Your article has left me in awe, thank you for sharing such a gem! This is the Latest test HL7-FHIR questions answers exam I took to get my promotion and pay raise, now available to you for free today. I hope you reach your professional goals soon!
CIS-CSM試験に合格して証明書を取得する方法に関する質問を検討していますか？最良の答えは、CIS-CSMクイズトレントをダウンロードして学習することです。 CIS-CSM試験の質問は、必要なものを短時間で取得するのに役立ちます。 CIS-CSMトレーニング準備を購入した後、Jpshikenダウンロードしてインストールするのに少し時間が必要です。その後、学習するのに約20〜30時間かかります。 CIS-CSM試験ガイドをご覧いただき、貴重な時間を割いていただければ幸いです。
今はHP HPE0-V26試験に準備するために、分厚い本を購買しなくてあまりにも多くのお金をかかるトレーニング機構に参加する必要がありません。我々社のHPE0-V26練習問題は試験に参加する圧力を減らすだけでなく、お金を無駄にする煩悩を解消できます。あなたは弊社の商品を使用した後、一回でHP HPE0-V26試験に合格できなかったら、弊社は全額返金することを承諾します。
The article was full of valuable insights. This Reliable exam NSE7_OTS-7.2 experience helped me secure a promotion and salary increase. Now it’s free for everyone. Best wishes for your career advancement!
This article is truly inspiring, and it has given me a new understanding of the related topic. The C1000-172 Real Questions content is incredibly helpful, and it’s available to you for free.
Your article really stood out, I’m so grateful for it. I’m offering the QV12DA latest test cram materials exam that helped me land my promotion and pay raise. It’s free today—good luck achieving your career goals!
ITDumpsKR에서는 Microsoft인증 MS-900-KR시험을 도전해보시려는 분들을 위해 퍼펙트한 Microsoft인증 MS-900-KR덤프를 가벼운 가격으로 제공해드립니다.덤프는Microsoft인증 MS-900-KR시험의 기출문제와 예상문제로 제작된것으로서 시험문제를 거의 100%커버하고 있습니다. ITDumpsKR제품을 한번 믿어주시면 기적을 가져다 드릴것입니다.
Clicking that like—this content deserves it. Sharpen your IT knowledge with free IAM-Certificate certification exam infor. Wishing you success!
I’m in awe of this article, thank you for sharing it with us! Thanks to the Reliable C-HRHFC-2411 exam online, I got promoted and received a raise. Now, I’m offering it for free to everyone. Best of luck in your career endeavors!
Through this article, I have gained a deep understanding of this topic and benefited immensely. Please wish me all the best for the upcoming New OMG-OCSMP-MU100 test simulator fee exam!
Thank you for sharing such a motivational and uplifting article! Unlock career success with the free Pass-guaranteed H35-663 dumps exam questions—boost your promotion and salary!
I appreciate your share, the article is simply brilliant! Heading into the H13-711-ENU valid dumps book exam soon. Pray for me!
This article is very insightful and has helped me better understand many complex concepts. Test JN0-223 valid offers abundant material at no cost, meant to assist in your learning.
Your website has helped me in so many ways ติดต่อหวยฮานอย
The content is on point, so I’m liking it. Valid C1000-005 exam vce provides excellent materials, and they are free to access.
I was amazed by the insights in that article. Get access to the C_HRHPC_2411 latest exam simulator exam that helped me achieve a promotion and pay raise, now free for everyone today. Best wishes in your professional development!
I’m so grateful for your article, it truly grabbed my attention. The New CCSP study materials questions are free for everyone. Good luck on your exams!
Welche Methode der Prüfungsvorbereitung mögen Sie am meisten? Mit PDF, online Test machen oder die simulierte Prüfungssoftware benutzen? Alle drei Methoden können CompTIA CV0-003 von unserer ITZert Ihnen bieten. Demos aller drei Versionen von Prüfungsunterlagen können Sie vor dem Kauf kostenfrei herunterladen und probieren. Die beste Methode zu wählen ist ein wichtiger Schritt zum Bestehen der CompTIA CV0-003. Zweifellos garantieren wir, dass jede Version von CompTIA CV0-003 Prüfungsunterlagen umfassend und wirksam ist.
Your article is outstanding; thank you for sharing it! Free Reliable CTFL-Foundation exam cram available for improving your IT skills. Wishing you the best!
It was such a valuable learning experience. I used the Test H19-402_V1.0 questions fee to climb the career ladder and earn a salary raise. It’s now free for everyone. Best of luck with your career!
It provided me with a fresh perspective. The Valid D-MN-OE-23 test practice test played a big part in my career growth, and I’m offering it to you for free today!
The article is full of motivational insights, thank you for sharing! Free ITIL-4-Foundation reliable exam dumps file resources are shared—good luck to all!
Your article is really impressive, thank you for sharing! These NCP-CI-AWS reliable mock exam questions were the key to my success. Grab them today for free to boost your career!
DP-203学習ガイドには、PDF、ソフトウェア/ PC、およびアプリ/オンラインの3つのモードがあります。 分散した時間を使用して、自宅にいるのか、会社にいるのか、外出中にいるのかを知ることができます。 同時に、DP-203学習テストの内容は、暦年の試験シラバスの内容に従って専門家によって慎重にMicrosoft編集されます。 DP-203学習教材を使用すると、DP-203テストを受ける前に練習するのに20〜30時間しかかからず、98％〜100％の高いData Engineering on Microsoft Azure合格率が得られます。
Cisco인증350-601시험의자격증은 여러분에 많은 도움이 되리라 믿습니다. 하시는 일에서 한층 더 업그레이드될 것이고 생활에서도 분명히 많은 도움이 될 것입니다. 자격증취득 즉 재산을 얻었죠.Cisco인증350-601시험은 여러분이 it지식테스트시험입니다. Pass4Test에서는 여러분의 편리를 위하여 Pass4Test만의 최고의 최신의Cisco 350-601덤프를 추천합니다. Pass4Test를 선택은 여러분이 최고의 선택입니다. Pass4Test는 제일 전면적인Cisco 350-601인증시험자료의 문제와 답을 가지고 잇습니다.
This article is deep, and I’ve learned many valuable experiences from it. Free CTPRP dump check resources are available! Best of luck to all!
This article is truly stunning, thank you for sharing it with us. The C-SAC-2421 Test Questions questions are essential for your career—get them for free now!
Your article was so refreshing, I really appreciate it. Wishing for a smooth Latest H12-821_V1.0 exam experience exam ahead. Wish me luck!
既然通過Cisco 200-901 認證考試是不容易的，那麼選擇好的培訓工具就是成功的保證。Testpdf會第一時間為你提供考試資料及考試練習題和答案，讓你為Cisco 200-901 認證考試做好充分的準備，以確保能100%通過Cisco 200-901 認證考試。Testpdf不僅能讓你首次參加Cisco 200-901 認證考試就成功通過，還能幫你節約寶貴的時間。
如果你選擇了Fast2test的幫助，我們一定不遺餘力地幫助你通過考試。而且我們還會為你提供一年的免費的更新考試練習題和答案的售後服務。不用再猶豫了！請選擇Fast2test，它將會是你通過AD0-E902認證考試的最好保證。快將Fast2test加入你的購物車吧！
I’m so impressed with this article, thank you for your generosity in sharing. The Latest 220-1101 practice exam fee test papers are now available for free. Wishing you all the best!
Your article is astonishing, I truly appreciate you sharing it! The LEED-AP-BD-C Standard Answers material is top-notch, and I hope it assists you, with no cost involved.
I’m genuinely grateful for your share, this article is fantastic! Reliable 300-540 test dumps file provides a lot of useful material, offered at no charge to help you.
This article has given me a new understanding of this field, and it’s truly inspiring. Exam 1Z0-931-24 discount provides a lot of useful material, offered at no charge to help you.
あらゆる種類の試験を扱う場合、最も重要なことは、効果的にレビューするための科学的な方法を見つけることです。最も専門的な専門家によって編集された当社のE_BW4HANA214練習資料。現在まで、世界中の何万人ものお客様がE_BW4HANA214試験トレントをサポートしています。 E_BW4HANA214学習教材に不慣れな場合は、参考のために無料のデモをダウンロードしてください。一部の未学習の試験の受験者は、E_BW4HANA214練習教材で必需品をすばやく習得できます。したがって、教材は欠かすことのできない要素教材です。
Thank you for your article; it really opened my eyes! The 1Z0-1073-23 latest exam study guide questions were essential to my promotion and salary boost, and today, I’m sharing them with you for free!
Your article was amazing, I’m truly grateful for it. Latest NetSec-Generalist exam objectives provides valuable content at no cost to you.
Die Lerntipps zur SHRM SHRM-SCP Prüfung von PrüfungFrage können ein Leuchtturm in Ihrer Karriere sein. Denn es enthält alle Prüfungsfragen und Antworten zur SHRM-SCP Zertifizierung. Wählen Sie PrüfungFrage und es kann Ihnen helfen, die SHRM SHRM-SCP Prüfung zu bestehen. Das ist absolut eine weise Entscheidung. PrüfungFrage ist Ihr Helfer und Sie können bessere Resultate bei weniger Einsatz erzielen.
현재EMC D-PST-DY-23인증시험을 위하여 노력하고 있습니까? 빠르게EMC인증 D-PST-DY-23시험자격증을 취득하고 싶으시다면 우리 Itcertkr 의 덤프를 선택하시면 됩니다,. Itcertkr를 선택함으로EMC D-PST-DY-23인증시험패스는 꿈이 아닌 현실로 다가올 것입니다,
Wir alle wissen, dass im Zeitalter des Internets ist es ganz einfach, die Informationen zu bekommen. Aber was fehlt ist nämlich, Qualität und Anwendbarkeit. Viele Leute suchen im Internet die Schulungsunterlagen zur Adobe AD0-E902 Zertifizierungsprüfung. Und Sie wissen einfach nicht, ob sie zuverlässig sind. Hier empfehle ich Ihnen die Schulungsunterlagen zur Adobe AD0-E902 Zertifizierungsprüfung von ZertSoft. Sie haben im Internet die höchste Kauf-Rate und einen guten Ruf. Sie können im Internet Teil der Prüfungsfragen und Antworten zur Adobe AD0-E902 Zertifizierungsprüfung von ZertSoft kostenlos herunterladen. Dann können Sie entscheiden, ZertSoft zu kaufen oder nicht. Und Sie können auch die Echtheit von ZertSoft kriegen.