Minimum wage: wage subsidy is the solution to income disparity
First published on WION.
The recent one-day general strike on the 2nd of September brought several parts of the country to a standstill. Among the demands of the trade unions was one for raising the minimum wage to Rs. 18,000 per month. The NDA government, in an attempt to ward off the strike, had announced a hike earlier in the week from Rs. 246 per day to Rs. 350 per day (Rs. 9,100 per month for 26 working days). The unions, with the exception of the RSS-affiliated Bharatiya Mazdoor Sangh, denounced the government’s efforts and the strike went ahead as planned.
Trade unions in India have historically fought for periodic raises in minimum wages. In 2013 there was a nationwide strike (20-21 February) during which one of the demands was for a minimum wage of Rs. 10,000 per month. There was a similar strike on 2nd September 2015 in which a minimum wage demand for Rs. 15,000 a month was made. But even though the unions have been raising this issue consistently for the past several years, increases have been paltry.
Minimum wages in India are regulated under The Minimum Wages Act (1948) and there are wage floors that, in the words of the Act, “ensure that the laws of demand and supply are not allowed to determine the wages of workmen in industries where workers are poor, vulnerable, unorganised, and without bargaining power.” Thus, it is based on moral or ethical and not only economic principles.
The method of calculation of the “need-based” minimum wage dates back to 1957 when the Indian Labour Congress came up with a formula that included food, clothing, and shelter requirements for a family of four. The exact amount of the wage differs based on the occupation and geographical region. The Indian states have the freedom to set higher minimums, but conceptually these wages constitute the minimum level that the central government thinks those who work for it should earn.
After periodic inflation adjustments, the minimum wage is now in the range of Rs. 9,100 to 13,600 depending on the geographical location of the worker. One may ask, whether this constitutes a living wage in India today for a family of four. Given the rapid increases in the price of housing, education, health, and food in the past few years, the answer must be in the negative. The concept of a “living wage” as distinct from a “minimum wage” has recently gained a lot of political traction in countries such as the United States.
The Committee on Fair Wages in India has defined a “living wage” that includes education, health, social needs, and insurance in addition to food, shelter and clothing. Studies have shown that rapid increases in expenditures on items such as education, health, fuel, and conveyance have cut into people’s food budgets. Indeed rise in non-food expenditures has been advanced as one of the explanations for India’s famous calorie puzzle wherein nutritional intake has been falling even as incomes are increasing in real terms. With these economic facts in mind, the claim that the official minimum wage is not a living wage and the demand for a much larger increase in the minimum wage are both justified.
An even more important issue is that, while the central and to some extent the state governments can try to enforce the minimum wages for their own employees (either direct or employed via contractors), enforcing them in the informal or unorganised sector where the vast majority of the Indian labour force earns a living is another kettle of fish.
The present increase in wages applies to unskilled non-agricultural workers in the central sphere, which means employees of the central government or workers in affiliated undertakings in occupations, such as stone breaking and crushing, mining, sweeping and cleaning, loading, unloading, construction et cetra. The National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganised Sector (the Sengupta Commission), which became famous for observing that 77 per cent of Indians spent Rs. 20 a day or less in 2004-05, observed that even though The Minimum Wages Act covers all workers in the formal and the informal sectors, several studies have shown that the vast majority of informal sector workers are paid below the official minimum wage for their occupation.
In some instances, there exists no official minimum wage for a given occupation, so the question of compliance does not arise. Further millions of workers in the informal sector do not receive daily wages but instead, work on their own account (self-employment) or are paid in piece wages that are not easy to convert into time wages in the absence of data on usual working hours. The earnings of such home-based and other workers often fall well short of even the low official minimum wage.
In my own fieldwork in the textile industry in Varanasi, I found that weavers were routinely paid piece wages that translated into daily wages of around Rs. 100-150 per day (in 2010), far below the stipulated minimum wage for skilled silk weavers in Uttar Pradesh, which at that time was more than Rs. 200.
The situation was even worse for women workers who were paid as low as Rs. 25 to 30 per day for embroidery work. A 2010 study by the All India Democratic Women’s Association (AIDWA) in the Delhi-NCR region found that even after working for nearly seven hours a day home-based women workers managed to earn only Rs.32.54 per day. The daily minimum wage for unskilled workers in Delhi at the time was Rs.140. Abysmally low wages for women are often justified on grounds that they are “supplementary earners” or that they work in “spare time”. Both these are questionable, not to say sexist, assumptions.
How then, can we ensure that at least the basic minimum standard of living that the government stipulates should accrue to every Indian family does, in fact, accrue to them? One way to do this is to end contract work as well as the practice of allowing informal workers in formal establishments, including public sector ones. This will make wage implementation easier. This was indeed one of the demands of the general strike as well.
In the post-reform period, employment of contract workers has become a prominent feature of the way private sector firms and even public ones operate to reduce labour costs and increase flexibility. The result has been a rapid rise in contract labour and almost no increase in regular formal jobs that come with some measure of job security and other benefits.
But what about the vast numbers who work in the informal economy beyond informal employment in formal establishments? As mentioned above, the millions of workers in India’s small workshops, shops, and homes who produce a large variety of goods and services from food, metalware, and textiles to mobile and auto repair earn wages far below the official minimum. Most of these businesses are tiny, employing fewer than 10 workers each. Won’t forcing such businesses to pay higher wages, closer to the official minimum wage, result in them going out of business and destroying jobs?
This is indeed a possibility because many informal businesses do operate on very small margins. In such cases, a wage subsidy, where the government supplements private sector incomes up to a certain level, may be the way to go. We are familiar with various subsidies that the government gives to the industrial sector in the form of tax breaks, depreciation allowances, SEZs, price supports etc. However, thousands of crores of rupees worth of such subsidies have not been particularly effective in creating jobs as the subsidising capital, not surprisingly, incentivises capital-intensive production.
Instead of subsidising capital, if we seriously believe that the official minimum wage constitutes an ethical lower bound on what a worker should earn then why not subsidise labour such that informal sector wages rise to that lower bound? Such a “wage subsidy” has recently been suggested by the well-known economist Pranab Bardhan.
Unlike a capital subsidy, this will encourage job creation as opposed to merely economic growth. It will also have large effects in boosting spending in the economy at a time when weak demand has been an important constraint on economic growth. Further, it will end the dualism between the formal sector with its minimum and inflation-indexed wages, and the informal sector that enjoys no such protection. Moreover, it will end it by moving the informal up to the level of the formal instead of bringing the formal down by informalising it, as has been the practice thus far in the post-reform period.
Any kind of job should be having a minimum wage.
https://www.fooddoz.com
UK Embroidery Digitizing Company, we take pride in delivering top-notch digitization services to our clients. With a team of skilled professionals and cutting-edge technology, we strive to transform your designs into stunning embroidered masterpieces. From intricate logos to detailed artwork, we ensure precision and quality in every stitch.
Immerse yourself in the challenging journey of Drift Boss, where you will drive through sharp turns and dangerous slopes.
IT인증자격증은 국제적으로 승인받는 자격증이기에 많이 취득해두시면 취업이나 승진이나 이직이나 모두 편해집니다. 다른 사람이 없는 자격증을 내가 가지고 있다는것은 실력을 증명해주는 수단입니다. ServiceNow인증 CIS-VR시험은 널리 승인받는 자격증의 시험과목입니다. ServiceNow인증 CIS-VR덤프로ServiceNow인증 CIS-VR시험공부를 하시면 시험패스 난이도가 낮아지고 자격증 취득율이 높이 올라갑니다.자격증을 많이 취득하여 취업이나 승진의 문을 두드려 보시면 빈틈없이 닫힌 문도 활짝 열릴것입니다.
This article has given me a new understanding of this field, and it’s truly inspiring. The Latest NSE5_FMG-7.2 practice questions pdf test questions are now available for free—your career success is just a step away!
The content is top-notch, liking it right now. I secured a promotion and salary boost with the D-MN-OE-23 test practice. Now, it’s free for all. Wishing you all success and career growth!
現在、E-BW4HANA214認証試験に助けがある参考資料を提供するサイトがあります。我々は過去の試験のデータを整理し分析して、E-BW4HANA214問題集を研究することができます。我々の研究成果は100％試験に合格するのを保証することができます。我々Xhs1991の支援で、あなたはE-BW4HANA214試験に合格することだけでなく、時間とお金を節約することができます。
That article made me think deeply about things. Reliable AD0-E906 real test question was crucial for my career advancement and salary boost—I’m giving them away for free today!
This article is absolutely top-tier, thank you for sharing. Good luck! Here are the Latest 1z1-071 exam braindumps materials shared for free.
The article gave me a whole new outlook on things. Sharing the Latest study guide D-PST-MN-A-24 files test papers for free. Best of luck!
I deeply appreciate your article, it was truly memorable. Upgrade your IT abilities—free C_TS462_2023 reliable exam duration is now available! Best of luck to all!
The content is on fire—like is clicked. The Latest FCSS_SOC_AN-7.4 exam pdf content is amazing, and it’s available to you without charge.
I can’t help but hit like—this content is that good. With this Valid practice questions Data-Cloud-Consultant book, I earned my promotion and salary boost. It’s free for everyone now. Wishing you all success in your career advancement!
Wir Pass4Test sind die professionellen Anbieter der Schulungsunterlagen zur Axis ANVE Zertifizierungsprüfung. Seit langem betrachten wir Pass4Test das Angebot der besten Prüfungsunterlagen zur Axis ANVE Zertifizierungsprüfung als unser Ziel. Verglichen zu anderen Webseiten, wir Pass4Test sind immer von anderen vertraut. Warum? Weil wir Pass4Test vieljährige Erfahrungen haben, aufmerksam auf die IT-Zertifizierung-Studie machen und viele Prüfungsregeln sammeln. Damit können wir Pass4Test sehr hohe Hit-Rate haben. Das gewährleistet die Durchlaufrate.
Wenn Sie einen Traum haben, dann sollen Sie Ihren Traum verteidigen. Gorki hat einmal gesagt, dass der Glaube ist ein großes Gefühl und eine kreative Kraft ist. MeinTraum ist es, ein Top-IT-Experte zu werden. Ich denke, dass es für mich nirgends in Sicht ist. Aber Erfolg können Sie per eine Abkürzung gelingen, solange Sie die richtige Wahl treffen. Ich benutzte die ZertFragen VMware 5V0-31.22 Prüfung Fragenkataloge, und habe die VMware 5V0-31.22 Zertifizierungsprüfung bestanden. Die Fragenkataloge zur VMware 5V0-31.22 Prüfung von ZertFragen sind die besten Lernhilfe. Wenn Sie wie ich einen IT-Traum haben. Dann kaufen Sie Prüfungsfragen und Antworten von ZertFragen. ZertFragenes wird Ihnen helfen, Ihren Traum zu verwirklichen.
Jpexam有効なAZ-500J研究急流がなければ、Microsoftあなたの利益はあなたの努力に比例しないといつも感じていますか？ あなたは常に先延ばしに苦しみ、散発的な時間を十分に活用できないと感じていますか？ 答えが完全に「はい」の場合は、高品質で効率的なテストツールであるAZ-500Jトレーニング資料を試してみることをお勧めします。 AZ-500J試験に合格し、夢のあるAZ-500JのMicrosoft Azure Security Technologies (AZ-500日本語版)認定を取得することで、あなたの成功は100％保証され、より高い収入やより良い企業により多くの機会を得ることができます。
I’m in awe of your article, thank you so much for sharing! The IIA-CIA-Part2 reliable study materials exam questions are free for everyone—boost your career and salary today!
What a fantastic article, thank you for sharing such an amazing piece! New free study CRT-450 questions offers excellent resources for free.
자신을 부단히 업그레이드하려면 많은 노력이 필요합니다. IT업종 종사자라면 국제승인 IT인증자격증을 취득하는것이 자신을 업그레이드하는것과 같습니다. EMC인증 DEA-7TT2시험을 패스하여 원하는 자격증을 취득하려면KoreaDumps의EMC인증 DEA-7TT2덤프를 추천해드립니다. 하루빨리 덤프를 공부하여 자격증 부자가 되세요.
Your article really stuck with me, I’m sincerely grateful. We are offering New Salesforce-MuleSoft-Developer-I exam fee, full of valuable content, for free, hoping it proves helpful.
What an amazing article, I truly appreciate your insight. Get the New NSE7_EFW-7.2 braindumps sheet questions for free—your promotion and salary increase start now!
IT인증시험을 쉽게 취득하는 지름길은ExamPassdump에 있습니다. ExamPassdump의CompTIA인증 SK0-005덤프로 시험준비를 시작하면 성공에 가까워집니다. CompTIA인증 SK0-005덤프는 최신 시험문제 출제방향에 대비하여 제작된 예상문제와 기출문제의 모음자료입니다. CompTIA인증 SK0-005덤프는 시험을 통과한 IT업계종사자분들이 검증해주신 세련된 공부자료입니다. ExamPassdump의CompTIA인증 SK0-005덤프를 공부하여 자격증을 땁시다.
This content is incredible, liking it without delay. FCSS_NST_SE-7.4 reliable visual cert exam provides free, abundant content, designed to help you succeed.
I am so grateful for your share, this article is truly impressive! This is the C-THR82-2411 latest study guide free test that helped me secure a promotion and raise. It’s free for everyone today—wishing you all the best in your career!
Reading this article has helped me plan for my future work. Time to tackle the New 300-820 exam simulator fee exam! Fingers crossed!
Thank you for your article, it was so insightful and inspiring. Sharing the Flexible MuleSoft-Platform-Architect-I testing engine exam that got me my promotion and salary raise—it’s free for all today. Hope you all achieve your professional dreams!
Your article was truly refreshing, thank you so much. The Valid study guide C-THR97-2405 free test questions are the key to career success—now shared for free!
EMC D-MSS-DS-23試験参考書を利用すれば、あなたは多くの時間を節約するだけでなく、いろいろな知識を身につけます。最も重要なのは、D-MSS-DS-23認定試験資格証明書を取得できるということです。また、D-MSS-DS-23試験参考書の合格率は高いので、D-MSS-DS-23試験に落ちる必要がないです。
あなたは今やはりC_THR97_2405試験に悩まされていますか？長い時間C_THR97_2405試験を取り組んいる弊社はあなたにC_THR97_2405練習問題を提供できます。あなたはC_THR97_2405試験に興味を持たれば、今から行動し、C_THR97_2405練習問題を買いましょう。C_THR97_2405試験に合格するために、C_THR97_2405練習問題をよく勉強すれば、いい成績を取ることが難しいことではありません。つまりC_THR97_2405練習問題はあなたの最も正しい選択です。
Such an extraordinary article, I deeply appreciate your sharing. Don’t miss the free Salesforce-AI-Associate exam testking questions—the key to promotion and higher pay!
I appreciate the straightforward layout and organization of your site. หวย ฮานอย lotto
Wenn Sie ZertPruefung wählen, steht der Erfolg schon vor der Tür. Und bald können Sie Juniper JN0-252 Zertifikat bekommen. Das Produkt von ZertPruefung bietet Ihnen 100%-Pass-Garantie und auch einen kostenlosen einjährigen Update-Service.
EMC D-PM-IN-23인증시험패스 하는 동시에 여러분의 인생에는 획기적인 일 발생한것이죠, 사업에서의 상승세는 당연한것입니다. IT업계종사자라면 누구나 이런 자격증을 취득하고싶어하리라고 믿습니다. 많은 분들이 이렇게 좋은 인증시험은 아주 어렵다고 생각합니다. 네 많습니다. 패스할확율은 아주 낮습니다. 노력하지않고야 당연히 불가능하죠.EMC D-PM-IN-23시험은 기초지식 그리고 능숙한 전업지식이 필요요 합니다. 우리Fast2test는 여러분들한테EMC D-PM-IN-23시험을 쉽게 빨리 패스할 수 있도록 도와주는 사이트입니다. 우리Fast2test의EMC D-PM-IN-23시험관련자료로 여러분은 짧은시간내에 간단하게 시험을 패스할수 있습니다. 시간도 절약하고 돈도 적게 들이는 이런 제안은 여러분들한테 딱 좋은 해결책이라고 봅니다.
I really appreciate your article, it has made a big impression on me. The Updated D-MN-OE-23 dumps test was a key factor in my professional growth, and now I’m sharing it with you for free!
That article was a real treasure trove of knowledge. The free Reliable CPHQ practice questions free test materials are available for all. Good luck!
Straight to the like button, this content is fantastic. The Excellect C_THR83_2411 pass rate exam is coming soon. Fingers crossed for success!
I feel like I’ve gained so much from it. Test IIA-CIA-Part1 preparation questions for free! Best of luck to everyone sitting for the exam!
This article is brilliant, and I’ve gained a lot of inspiration from it. Thanks to the Pdf 312-82 format, I got promoted and received a salary raise. Now, I’m offering it for free. Wishing you all success in your careers!
What an impressive article, thank you for sharing your wisdom! ISO-IEC-27005-Risk-Manager latest exam braindumps gives you a wealth of free content, created to assist you.
This article truly broadened my horizons; thank you for sharing! With the IAA-IAP valid exam camp sheet, I achieved a promotion and pay raise. Now, it’s free for everyone. Best of luck with your career progression!
Thank you for sharing this incredible article, it’s truly breathtaking! The HPE0-V28 latest exam discount materials are excellent, and they’re totally free.
PL-900テスト準備は高品質です。合格率とヒット率は両方とも高いです。合格率は約98％-100％です。試験に合格する可能性が非常に高いことを保証できます。 PL-900ガイドトレントは、専門家によって編集され、豊富な経験を持つ専門家によって承認されています。 PL-900のFast2test準備トレントは、高品質の製品であり、精巧にコンパイルされ、以前の試験の論文と業界で人気のある傾向に従って、厳密な分析と要約が行われました。 PL-900試験の教材の言語はシンプルで理解しやすいです。
This article is a real treasure, thank you for sharing it with us. The New SCS-C02 exam cram pdf materials are first-rate, and they’re available for free.
What an encouraging read, thank you for sharing this article! Get your hands on the free D-DP-DS-23 latest test collection file exam questions. Wishing you the best of luck!
Your article left me in awe, I’m grateful for your share! Best of luck with your exams—free SPLK-1003 valid test bootcamp materials exam papers are available now!
KoreaDumps의 경험이 풍부한 전문가들이CompTIA DA0-001인증시험관련자료들을 계획적으로 페펙트하게 만들었습니다.CompTIA DA0-001인증시험응시에는 딱 좋은 자료들입니다. KoreaDumps는 최고의 덤프만 제공합니다. 응시 전CompTIA DA0-001인증시험덤프로 최고의 시험대비준비를 하시기 바랍니다.
What an enlightening and motivating read, thank you for sharing! The CIS-ITSM valid test collection sheet study materials are available for free—good luck!
I’m amazed by your article, thank you for such an extraordinary share! Here goes the MD-102 test syllabus exam! Hoping for success!