The curious case of ‘Jobless growth’ in India
First published on The Dialog.
The problem of “jobless growth” under the wider umbrella of Indian economy has attracted a lot of attention in media recently. Of all the challenges thrown up by the neoliberal reforms of the late 1980s and early 1990s, this one is among the most serious and the one with potentially catastrophic long-term consequences, if not addressed soon. One way to visualize the seriousness of the problem is via the data presented in Figure 1 below. It shows annual growth rates of GDP and of formal sector employment over ten year periods starting in the 1970s. Notice that while GDP growth becomes faster, employment growth becomes slower. During the pre-economic crisis spurt in GDP growth where the Indian economy grew at an average annual rate of over 8%, the rate of formal job growth was less than 0.5% per year. The result has a persistent informality and casualness of employment and lack of stable jobs with benefits and inflation-adjusted wages.
Figure 1: Jobless Growth
The previous UPA government’s inability to create jobs acted as a catalyst for a change and Modi campaign promised a much more rapid rate of employment growth. While more time may pass to see if they achieve this, the initial indications are that the problem will persist. Quarterly job creation data from the Labour Ministry shown in Figure 2 suggests that, if anything, jobs are being created more slowly under the present regime. The figure shows cumulative jobs added each quarter since the end of 2008 up to the end of 2015.
Figure 2: Quarterly formal sector job creation (Labour Ministry data)
Some of the reasons for such a sluggish growth might be mechanization, global competition, skill mismatch, and labor strife, however are these discourses being addressed at the policy level? While global economic conditions and factors outside the control of Indian policy-makers may be part of the reason, it is equally the result of self-imposed ideologically motivated constraints.
It is true that increased openness to trade and capital, places certain important constraints on developing country government who might want to pursue policies that depart from the “Washington Consensus.” But scholars such as Dani Rodrik have argued in his book, One Economics, Many Recipes, that developing country policy-makers are not even using the policy freedom that does exist in order to suit their own domestic conditions and meet their own challenges. Instead they are choosing to accept deregulation, liberalisation, and openness as goods in themselves rather than as one among many policy options to be followed selectively in the pursuit of broad development goals.
A case in point is the obsession with labour laws and lack of flexibility in the labour market as the reason for lack of formal job creation. Despite the fact that surveys show, constraints such as lack of infrastructure and weak demand are much more binding than labour laws (for e.g. see Kotwal, Ramaswami and Wadhwa 2011).This is even truer of employers in micro, small and medium enterprises, who often operate well under the ceiling at which labour laws apply and can hire many employees before the laws kick in, but who are still unable to expand employment because of inadequate electricity, lack of access to markets and/or credit, and weak demand.
Another case is aversion to the very mention of any “industrial policy” for fear of a return to the “license-quota-permit raj.” Never mind that the entire gamut of policies followed under the neoliberal regime, such as Special Economic Zones, FDI, Make in India and so on are all industrial policy measures, though not labeled as such. Industrial policy in the service of export promotion and foreign investment is welcomed and any policy focusing on domestic firms and markets is viewed with suspicion and has to prove itself twice as hard.
An employment-first development strategy will involve fundamentally different choices than the growth-first strategy that we have followed for the past 25 years and that has brought us to the present-day crisis. It is clear that such a strategy cannot be implemented if precedence is given to the latest technology (which almost always has been developed in labour-scarce, capital-abundant contexts) and to global competitiveness. But such is the hold of these two ideologies that the merest mention of departing from them invites allegations of wanting to “take India back” to some dark time. Of course these allegations come from those whom the present economic regime has blessed with well-paying, secure jobs; precisely the thing that is denied to the vast majority by the very same regime.
It is now abundantly clear that uncritically accepting deregulation, trade openness and openness to capital flows (FDI or short-term) leads to highly undesirable outcomes such as increasing capital intensity of production, resulting in growth without jobs. The solution to this is not more globalization and reliance on some mythical foreign demand (for which the moment may, in any case, have passed), but rather doing the hard work of designing appropriately open trade policy, providing key infrastructure, particularly to MSMEs, and raising rural incomes (and therefore demand) by raising public investment in agriculture. After all sound agricultural policy is the bedrock of any decent industrial policy.
exam bank
We keep up with the latest techniques of building and have qualified tradesmen to ensure that your job/project is carried out safely. We also make sure that we keep to the highest standards on projects and everyone who works for us is health & safety trained.
It was interesting for me to get more info about critical issue of “jobless growth” in India, and figure out\ how economic growth hasn’t translated into adequate job creation. I see the clear disconnect between rising GDP and stagnating employment, pointing out key factors like mechanization, global competition, and labor market issues. I worked on case study on this subject and read review https://medium.com/@george.kv/stemxperts-review-2024-f5fe0c7dfee1 that helped to gather more details about the shift in strategy—focusing less on deregulation and openness and more on fostering domestic demand and MSME support.
Pass4Test 는 여러분의 it전문가 꿈을 이루어드리는 사이트 입다. Pass4Test는 여러분이 우리 자료로 관심 가는 인중시험에 응시하여 안전하게 자격증을 취득할 수 있도록 도와드립니다. 아직도IBM C1000-138인증시험으로 고민하시고 계십니까?IBM C1000-138인증시험가이드를 사용하실 생각은 없나요? Pass4Test는 여러분에 편리를 드릴 수 잇습니다. Pass4Test의 자료는 시험대비최고의 덤프로 시험패스는 문제없습니다. Pass4Test의 각종인증시험자료는 모두기출문제와 같은 것으로 덤프보고 시험패스는 문제없습니다. Pass4Test의 퍼펙트한 덤프인 M crosoftC1000-138인증시험자료의 문제와 답만 열심히 공부하면 여러분은 완전 안전히IBM C1000-138인증자격증을 취득하실 수 있습니다.
This article truly broadened my horizons; thank you for sharing! Free Latest exam CPSA-FL sample questions exam papers are here. Wishing you the best of luck on your exam!
I deeply appreciate your share, this article is simply astonishing! Free MB-910 latest exam tutorial test papers—good luck to all!
CRM-Analytics-and-Einstein-Discovery-Consultant인증시험은Salesforce사의 인중시험입니다.Salesforce인증사의 시험을 패스한다면 it업계에서의 대우는 달라집니다. 때문에 점점 많은 분들이Salesforce인증CRM-Analytics-and-Einstein-Discovery-Consultant시험을 응시합니다.하지만 실질적으로CRM-Analytics-and-Einstein-Discovery-Consultant시험을 패스하시는 분들은 너무 적습니다.전분적인 지식을 터득하면서 완벽한 준비하고 응시하기에는 너무 많은 시간이 필요합니다.하지만 우리Itexamdump는 이러한 여러분의 시간을 절약해드립니다.
Thank you for the article; it really piqued my interest. Reliable 156-315.81 exam dumps file provides a variety of useful content, freely offered to support your learning.
Topexam製品の3つのバージョンを使用して、CIW Multimedia Specialist学習の質問は、PDFとソフトウェアとAPPバージョンの異なる用途を持つ顧客の異なる好みと好みを満たすことができますCIW。 質問の曖昧な点があなたを混乱させることなく、私たちの練習資料はあなたの試験に適した内容の本質を伝えることができます。 最も科学的な内容と専門的な資料1D0-724準備資料は、成功に不可欠です。 リーズナブルな価格でこのような価値ある買収があなたの目の前で提供され、あなたは十分に活用することを確信することができます。
Wir It-Pruefung bieten Ihnen die freundlichsten Kundendienst. Nach der Kauf der Symantec 250-586 Prüfungssoftware, bieten wir Ihnen kostenlosen Aktualisierungsdienst für ein voll Jahr, um Sie die neusten und die umfassendsten Unterlagen der Symantec 250-586 wissen zu lassen. Darum werden Sie sehr sicher sein, die Zertifizierungstest der Symantec 250-586 zu bestehen. Falls Sie unglücklich die Test der Symantec 250-586 nicht bei der ersten Proben bestehen, geben wir Ihnen die vollständige Gebühren zurück, um Iheren finanziellen Verlust zu entschädigen.
So much wisdom in this article, thank you for sharing it! Sharing S2000-018 free questions and answers materials for free—good luck on your exams!
Such a powerful article, thank you for sharing! Practice ANS-C01 Exam helped me land a promotion and salary increase. Now, I’m giving it to you for free!
This article is truly outstanding, thank you for sharing. Grab your free New 300-710 practice test fee test questions—promotion and salary increases await!
So good, I’m liking it without any delay. C-THR96-2405 free learning cram questions for free! Best of luck to everyone sitting for the exam!
This article is truly exceptional, thank you for sharing it with us. The D-PDC-DY-23 test sample questions material is very useful, and it’s available at no charge.
Your article was so impactful, I’m sincerely thankful for it. The Valid exam NS0-604 study guide questions are now free! Wishing you success in your exams!
I’m all about this content—definitely liking it. The C-S4FTR-2023 reliable test materials helped me land a promotion and salary boost. Now it’s free for all. Wishing you success in your career!
This article has been very helpful to me, and many of the ideas have been very inspiring. The Certification CA-Life-Accident-and-Health questions content is impressive, and it’s free for you to explore.
Thank you for sharing this insightful article, it really stood out to me. Free C_DBADM_2404 reliable test topics resources are the key to unlocking promotions and salary increases!
I love the content, so it’s an instant like for me. Here’s the P-S4FIN-2023 valid exam guide files test I took to earn my promotion and raise, now free for you today. Best of luck in your professional journey!
Your article is truly outstanding, thank you for sharing it with us! Ready to tackle the Reliable test ECBA cram review exam. Wishing for good results!
Thank you for your article; it is truly outstanding! I’m giving you access to the PDF 1Y0-204 Download test that helped me achieve a promotion and salary raise. It’s free today—wishing you success!