Income Inequality in India: Insights from the World Top Incomes Database

First published at Ideas For India.

Given the lack of reliable wage or asset data, tax returns-based World Top Incomes Database is important for measuring income and wealth inequalities. Analysing the India series of the database, this column find that starting in the 1980s average incomes grew faster than ever before, but that most of the gains went to the super rich. The trends mirror massive shifts in Indian political economy during that period.

Thomas Piketty’s bestseller ´Capital in the Twenty First Century’ has given a much-needed boost to the discussion on economic inequality in the long-run as well as during the neoliberal period. In India too, in the past decade, there have been a series of studies on various dimensions of inequality (Banerjee and Piketty 2005, Cain et al. 2010, Jayadev et al. 2007, Motiram and Vakulabharnam 2011, Pal and Ghosh 2007, Sen and Himanshu 2004, Vakulabharnam 2010). While consumption inequality is relatively easy to estimate based on household expenditure data, income and wealth inequalities are harder to measure particularly for developing countries where reliable wage or assets data is rarely available. The lack of data is even more pronounced for those at the top of the income or wealth distribution. Here the World Top Incomes Database (WTID) of 29 countries constructed by Piketty and colleagues using mainly income tax returns data becomes important (Alvaredo et al. 2014). While tax-based data suffer from several limitations for an economy like India’s which has a preponderance of informal (and hence officially untaxed) economic activity, tax evasion, and a narrow direct tax base, the WTID is an important complement to the National Sample Survey (NSS) data that typically underestimates inequality). WTID clearly illustrates the massive shift in Indian political economy in the 1980s, as seen through the lens of income inequality at the top of the distribution.
The WTID has been used to study the dynamics of inequality in several different countries (Atkinson et al. 2010). The series for India has been constructed by Abhijit Banerjee and Thomas Piketty using tax returns published in the ‘All-India Income-Tax Statistics’ (AIITS) series for the years 1922 to 1998 (and extrapolated to 1999).Banerjee and Piketty (2005) present income shares of the top 1%, 0.5%, 0.1% and 0.01% of the income distribution in India from 1922 to 1999, and compare the trends to those found in the US, UK and France. In this column, I extend their analysis by looking at trends in relative as well as absolute inequality, and calculating decadal growth rates in top incomes.2  I also place these trends in the context of India’s political economy Basole (2014).
Income inequality in India in the 20th century
The share in national income of the top 1%, 0.1%, and 0.01% peaked in the 1930s and then steadily declined following the Second World War and decolonisation (Figure 1, left). Throughout the planning period, inequality decreased continuously. The share of the top 1% fell to its lowest point (4.4%) in 1981 before starting to rise in the 1980s and accelerating in the 1990s. Note that the increase in inequality starts 10 years before the 1991 economic reforms. Banerjee and Piketty (2005) attribute this reversal to the pro-business policies brought in by the Indira Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi governments of that period. This view is consistent with other recent scholarship that has put forward the view that the neoliberal period in India starts in the mid-1980s, several years before the 1991 reforms (Kohli 2012, Rodrik and Subramanian 2004). I discuss this further in the next section.
A second point that emerges from Figure 1 (right panel) is that there has been a divergence within the top 1%, with the very top (0.01%) pulling away from the rest of the 1%. Consistent with the behaviour of the income distribution in other countries (Atkinson et al. 2010), inequality increases sharply at the top of the distribution. The 1% to average ratio in 1999 was 9:1, but the 0.1% to average ratio was 36:1 and the 0.01% to average ratio was 157:1. Strikingly, the 0.01% to average ratio, which had reached a historic high of 300:1 in the colonial period decreased significantly to 45:1 by 1979 before climbing back to 200:1 in 1995. Thus, a mere 15 years of a changed political economy were enough to restore a substantial portion of the inequality of the pre-independence period.
Figure 1. Income shares of the top 1%, 0.1%, and 0.01% (left) and top to average income ratios (right)
 
Source: Author’s calculations based on WTID.
The measures presented in Figure 1 show that inequality was on the rise throughout the 1980s and 1990s, though not reaching colonial levels. However, these relative inequality measures only give us part of the picture. Subramanian and Jayaraj (2013) and Ravallion (2014) have recently argued in favour of measuring absolute inequality in addition to relative inequality.3  A simple measure of absolute inequality is the real rupee difference (as opposed to the ratio) between the average income and the income of the top 1, 0.1, and 0.01%. To appreciate the difference between relative and absolute measures, note that if two incomes of say Rs. 1,000 and Rs. 10,000 increase, in real terms, to Rs. 2,000 and Rs. 20,000 respectively, the relative inequality, as measured by shares/ratios or the Gini coefficient,4  is unchanged but the absolute inequality has doubled from Rs. 9,000 to Rs. 18,000. This is clearly an important change in this hypothetical economy.
Figure 2 shows real incomes for all three categories over the data period. For reference purposes, the national average is reproduced at the top left. The subsequent charts add the real annual incomes of the rich (top 1%, top right), the super-rich (top 0.1%, bottom left), and the ultra-rich (top 0.01%, bottom right). Note that, even though the average income rises in real terms throughout, real incomes actually fell for the rich, very rich, and super rich during the 1960s and 1970s. Thus for the average to rise during this period, incomes in the middle and at the bottom have to have increased to compensate for this decline at the top. This indicates that economic growth though anaemic, was certainly more pro-poor during the planning period than afterwards.
Figure 2. Top incomes compared to average: Average (top left), top 1% added (top right), top 0.1% added (bottom left), and top 0.01% added (bottom right)
Source: WTID.
After reaching an all-time low in the late 1970s, top incomes rose, first slowly in the 1980s and then rapidly in the 1990s. During the 1980s and 1990s, all the losses experienced in the earlier decades were more than recovered and we see that absolute inequality increased in India to unprecedented levels (Figure 3). The 1990s are characterised by a pulling away of the 0.01% from the rest of the 1%. The real rupee difference in annual income between the top 0.1% and the 0.01% was Rs. 896,810 per year in 1990 but had ballooned to Rs. 3,099,421 per year in 1999, a three-fold increase.
As can be surmised from the data presented above, the planning period was not a good era for the growth of top incomes in the Indian economy. In particular, the 1960s and 1970s were decades during which average income grew at a decadal growth rate of around 10-12%, but incomes of the rich, very rich, and super rich fell sharply (Figure 4). The decadal growth rates for the three were -56%, -68%, and -79% respectively. But the situation had dramatically reversed itself by the end of the 1980s. The same growth rates in the very next decade were 54%, 55%, and 49%. In comparison, the national average grew by 23% in the 1980s as opposed to 12% in the 1970s. Another strong decade of top income growth in the 1990s more than restored the real incomes of the rich that had taken a hit in the turbulent 1970s.
 
Figure 3. Absolute inequality between the 0.01% and 0.1%, the 0.1% and 1%, and 1% and national average
 
Source: Author’s calculations based on WTID. 
Institutional context
The structural transformation that the Indian economy underwent in the 1980s is clearly reflected in the data presented here. A particularly striking aspect of the data is the sharp decline in real income at the top in the 1960s and 1970s. The prolonged industrial stagnation of this period (Raj 1976, Nayyar 1978) likely contributed to this. But several years before the economic reforms of 1991, incomes had recovered substantially. Allowing for artifacts such as improved ability of the State to tax incomes and increased incentives to pay tax due to reduced rates (which would also result in a rise in top incomes in the data), Banerjee and Piketty (2005) suggest that changing social norms, booming economy, international trade and globalisation can explain the rise. Indeed, the WTID data fits very well with the emerging view that a pro-business policy climate was the hallmark of the post-Emergency Indira Gandhi government as well as the Rajiv Gandhi government and that Indian political economy had shifted unmistakably from the Nehruvian Statist model to a pro-big business regime several years before the reforms of 1991 (Frankel 2005, Kohli 2012, Rodrik and Subramanian 2004). The result was a reversal of the industrial stagnation and industrial growth rate increased from 3.8% in the period 1965-1979 to 6.5% during 1980-1990 (Kohli 2012). As the emphasis shifted from redistributive justice to increasing productivity as well as private investment via relaxing of licensing requirements, taming labour, and host of other by-now familiar neoliberal policies, faster growth was indeed achieved, but the gains went disproportionately to the top.
Figure 4. Decadal growth in real incomes for the top 1%, 0.1%, and 0.01% compared to the national average
Source: Author’s calculations based on WTID. 
Conclusion
The WTID data clearly reveals the nature of growth experienced by the Indian economy since the 1980s. While average incomes grew faster than they ever did before, most of the gains went to the very top and inequality exploded. In absolute terms, inequality at the end of the 1990s was far higher than it had been even in the colonial period. India’s new political economy, taking shape since the 1980s, has failed to deliver inclusive growth.
Notes:
  1. For a detailed description of the Indian database, how it was constructed, and what its limitations are, the reader is referred to Banerjee and Piketty (2005). Unfortunately, the Government of India stopped publishing detailed tax return data after 1999, so the series stops there.
  2. The decadal growth rate is the rate of growth of income over a period of ten years.
  3. A relative inequality measure is unchanged when a distribution is uniformly scaled up or down by any factor. An absolute inequality measure is unchanged when the same value is added to or subtracted from every value in a distribution (Subramanian and Jayaraj 2013).
  4. The Gini coefficient is one of the most frequently used measures of inequality. It varies between 0 and 1 with a value of 0 indicating perfect equality (all households or individuals earning the same amount of income) and a value of 1 indicating perfect inequality (one household or individual earning all of society’s income).
Further Reading
  • Alvaredo, F, AB Atkinson, T Piketty, and E Saez (2014), ‘The World Top Incomes Database’.
  • Atkinson, AB and T Piketty (eds.) (2010), Top incomes: A global perspective, Oxford University Press.
  • Banerjee, Abhijit and Thomas Piketty (2005), “Top Indian Incomes, 1922–2000”, The World Bank Economic Review, 19(1), 1-20.
  • Basole, Amit (2014), “Dynamics of Income Inequality in India”, Economic & Political Weekly, 49(40), 15.
  • Cain, J. SalcedoRana Hasan, Rhoda Magsombol and Ajay Tandon (2010), “Accounting for inequality in India: Evidence from household expenditures”, World Development, 38(3), 282-297.
  • Frankel, F (2005), India’s Political Economy 1947-2004, Oxford University Press.
  • Jayadev, Arjun, Sripad Motiram and Vamsi Vakulabharanam (2007), “Patterns of wealth disparities in India during the liberalisation era”, Economic and Political Weekly, 3853-3863.
  • Kohli, A (2012), Poverty amid plenty in the new India, Cambridge University Press.
  • Motiram, S and V Vakulabharanam (2011), ‘Poverty and inequality in the age of economic liberalization’, India Development Report.
  • Pal, P and J Ghosh (2007), ‘Inequality in India: A survey of recent trends’, Economic and Social Affairs, Working Paper  No. 45.
  • Piketty, T (2014), Capital in the Twenty-first Century, Harvard University Press.
  • Raj, Kakkadan Nandanath (1976), “Growth and Stagnation in Indian Industrial Development”, Economic and Political Weekly, 11:5/7, pp. 223-236.
  • Rodrik, Dani and Arvind Subramanian (2004), ‘From” Hindu growth” to productivity surge: the mystery of the Indian growth transition’, National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No. 10376.
  • Nayyar, Deepak (1978), “Industrial Development in India: Some Reflections on Growth and Stagnation”, Economic and Political Weekly, 13:31/33, pp. 1265-1278.
  • Ravallion, Martin (2014), “Income Inequality in the Developing World”, Science, Vol. 344, No. 6186, pp. 851-855.
  • Sen, Abhijit and Himanshu (2004), “Poverty and Inequality in India: II: Widening Disparities during the 1990s”, Economic and Political Weekly, 4361-4375.
  • Subramanian, Sreenivasan and Dhairiyarayar Jayaraj (2013), “The Evolution of Consumption and Wealth Inequality in India: A Quantitative Assessment”, Journal of Globalization and Development, 4:2, pp. 253-81.
  • Vakulabharanam, Vamsi (2010), “Does class matter? Class structure and worsening inequality in India”, Economic and Political Weekly, 45(29), 67-76.

– See more at: http://www.ideasforindia.in/article.aspx?article_id=1496#sthash.QnBCYxg7.dpuf

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

54 comments

  1. William S. Eichhorn

    Thank you for sharing the insights on income inequality in India, they are just are eye-opening. It’s crucial to understand the underlying factors contributing to this issue and how it impacts society. In my free time, I explore different hobbies and I think that people can try making fun and money. It is just easy to see the list of MB online casinos and choose the platform that can increase your earnings. Maybe it can even help to resolve such a global issues, who knows..

  2. Carl Walsh

    It was a truly rewarding and enlightening piece of writing. Thanks to Valid testcollection L4M7, I secured a promotion and pay raise—today, I’m sharing it for free!

  3. James Nelson

    After reading this article, my understanding of the field has become more comprehensive. The D-PST-DY-23 exam passing score test played a big part in my career growth, and I’m offering it to you for free today!

  4. Carl Ward

    KoreaDumps의 도움을 받겠다고 하면 우리는 무조건 최선을 다하여 한번에 패스하도록 도와드릴 것입니다. 또한 일년무료 업뎃서비스를 제공합니다. 중요한 건 덤프가 갱신이 되면 또 갱신버전도 여러분 메일로 보내드립니다. 망설이지 마십시오. 우리를 선택하는 동시에 여러분은PCNSE시험고민을 하시지 않으셔도 됩니다.빨리 우리덤프를 장바구니에 넣으시죠.

  5. Arthur Gray

    PassTIP 에서 출시한 Amazon인증Data-Engineer-Associate시험덤프는 100%시험통과율을 보장해드립니다. 엘리트한 IT전문가들이 갖은 노력으로 연구제작한Amazon인증Data-Engineer-Associate덤프는 PDF버전과 소프트웨어버전 두가지 버전으로 되어있습니다. 구매전 PDF버전무료샘플로PassTIP제품을 체험해보고 구매할수 있기에 신뢰하셔도 됩니다. 시험불합격시 불합격성적표로 덤프비용을 환불받을수 있기에 아무런 고민을 하지 않으셔도 괜찮습니다.

  6. John Foster

    PassTIP에서는 전문SAP C_S4CS_2408인증시험을 겨냥한 덤프 즉 문제와 답을 제공합니다.여러분이 처음SAP C_S4CS_2408인증시험준비라면 아주 좋은 덤프입니다. PassTIP에서 제공되는 덤프는 모두 실제시험과 아주 유사한 덤프들입니다.SAP C_S4CS_2408인증시험패스는 보장합니다. 만약 떨어지셨다면 우리는 덤프비용전액을 환불해드립니다.

  7. Jon Hill

    The content is awesome, so I’m giving it a like. The content in Valid D-CS-DS-23 real test questions is comprehensive and offered for free, with your success in mind.

  8. Colin Harris

    I appreciate you sharing this article, it’s very inspiring! The Reliable E_S4CPE_2405 test collection file exam questions are free—your key to a brighter career and higher salary!

  9. Joe Shaw

    IT業界の一员として、君はまだIT認証試験を悩んでいますか?認証試験はITの専門知識を主なテストとして別に初めてIT関連のVMware認証試験に参加する受験生にとってはとても難しいとみされます。良い対応性の訓練が必要で、CertJuken の5V0-31.23問題集をお勧めます。

  10. Mike Black

    What a powerful piece, thank you for sharing this inspiring article! CGEIT latest test cram sheet questions are essential for your career success—get them for free!

  11. Bob Bell

    This article has caused me to re-examine many things, and I have greatly benefited from it. Get free access to Valid study guide 156-560 ppt exam questions—good luck to everyone!

  12. Nick Reed

    This article has truly inspired me, thank you for sharing! Test ACD-201 discount voucher helped me achieve the promotion and raise I dreamed of, and now I’m giving it to you for free!

  13. Jim Fisher

    I’m truly thankful for your article, it left a lasting and meaningful impression. The AACE-PSP pdf demo download questions are the key to unlocking promotions and salary raises—free for all!

  14. Gabe Hill

    지금 같은 상황에서 몇년간SAP C-HRHPC-2411시험자격증만 소지한다면 일상생활에서많은 도움이 될것입니다. 하지만 문제는 어떻게SAP C-HRHPC-2411시험을 간단하게 많은 공을 들이지 않고 시험을 패스할것인가이다? 우리Itcertkr는 여러분의 이러한 문제들을 언제드지 해결해드리겠습니다. 우리의C-HRHPC-2411시험마스터방법은 바로IT전문가들이제공한 시험관련 최신연구자료들입니다. 우리Itcertkr 여러분은C-HRHPC-2411시험관련 최신버전자료들을 얻을 수 있습니다. Itcertkr을 선택함으로써 여러분은 성공도 선택한것이라고 볼수 있습니다.

  15. Jack Lewis

    数万人の顧客は私たちの1z0-1067-24問題集を利用したら、1z0-1067-24試験に合格しました。もちろん、私たちの1z0-1067-24問題集を利用したら、唯一の収穫は試験に合格することではなく、自分の仕事またライフスタイルを変えることもできます。1z0-1067-24問題集のメリットはなんですか?いろいろありますよ。例えば、覚えやすい、便利、時間を節約するということなどです。

  16. Jon Ford

    Amazing stuff here, definitely hitting that like. The 100-160 reliable test registration test was my key to career success. Get it for free today and start advancing your career!

  17. Tom Wright

    I appreciate your article, it was so refreshing and insightful. These C-LIXEA-2404 valid exam pattern questions were the reason for my success, and now I’m offering them to you for free!

  18. Rick Martin

    Xhs1991が提供するCISSP試験の質問は、ISC専門家によって精巧にコンパイルされ、さまざまなバージョン(PDFバージョン、ソフトバージョン、APPバージョン)を強化します。 君は。 CISSPトレーニングブレインダンプは、他のダンプよりも安価であるだけでなく、より効果的です。 当社のCISSP学習教材の高い合格率は、数千人の候補者によって承認されており、彼らは当社のウェブサイトをCISSPのCertified Information Systems Security Professional (CISSP)試験に合格する唯一の学習ツールとして認識しています。

  19. Tom Bell

    Your article is absolutely awe-inspiring, thank you for sharing! The content in AZ-500 detailed study dumps is rich and free of charge, created with your success in mind.

  20. Ty Gray

    ITDumpsKR는 고객님께서Amazon CLF-C02-KR첫번째 시험에서 패스할수 있도록 최선을 다하고 있습니다. 만일 어떤 이유로 인해 고객님이Amazon CLF-C02-KR시험에서 실패를 한다면 ITDumpsKR는Amazon CLF-C02-KR덤프비용 전액을 환불 해드립니다. 시중에서 가장 최신버전인Amazon CLF-C02-KR덤프로 시험패스 예약하세요.

  21. Zack Brown

    This article is a real eye-opener, thanks for sharing! Free access to 350-201 latest study questions download’s rich content is available, hoping it benefits you in your studies.

  22. Ben Reed

    This article has caused me to re-examine many things, and I have greatly benefited from it. Here are the Exam dumps CTAL-TA provider questions for free! Best of luck to all candidates!

  23. Alan Lee

    Through reading this article, I feel that I have made great progress. The QSA_New_V4 latest exam duration questions are crucial for your career progression—get them for free!

  24. Jack Turner

    This article is a masterpiece in its own right, thank you for sharing. Hope the Valid braindumps DA0-001 free exam goes well! Please wish me luck!

  25. Ray Foster

    I deeply appreciate your share, this article is simply astonishing! Sharing the MLO pdf free exam that got me my promotion and salary raise—it’s free for all today. Hope you all achieve your professional dreams!

  26. Alexander Wood

    VMwareの5V0-92.22ソフトを使用するすべての人を有効にするために最も快適なレビュープロセスを得ることができ、我々は、VMwareの5V0-92.22の資料を提供し、PDF、オンラインバージョン、およびソフトバージョンを含んでいます。あなたの愛用する版を利用して、あなたは簡単に最短時間を使用してVMwareの5V0-92.22試験に合格することができ、あなたのIT機能を最も権威の国際的な認識を得ます!

  27. David Lee

    I’m grateful for your article, it was so refreshing and insightful. The C-CPE-16 certification sample questions questions are crucial for your career progression—get them for free!

  28. Jim Bell

    Sind Sie auf SAP C_THR89_2405 Zeritifizierungsprüfung bereit? Die Prüfungszeit ist angekommen. Sind Sie sehr selbstbewusst für die SAP C_THR89_2405 Prüfungen? Wenn Sie nicht sehr Selbstbewusst, empfehlen wir Ihnen die ausgezeichneten Prüfungsunterlagen. Mit den neuesten C_THR89_2405 Dumps von ZertPruefung können Sie in sehr beschränkter Zeit diese Prüfung zu bestehen.

  29. Tim Stone

    I appreciate your share, the article is simply brilliant! I’m sharing the AD0-E330 reliable practice questions free test that got me my promotion and pay raise. It’s available to you for free today—best of luck with your career ambitions!

  30. Max Green

    It-Pruefung ist eine Website, die den IT-Kandidaten die Schulungsunterlagen, die ganz speziell sind und den Kandidaten somit viel Zeit und Energie erspraen können, bietet. Unsere Prüfungsfragen und Antworten zur SAP C-THR97-2411 Zertifizierung sind den realen Themen sehr ähnlich. Mit Hilfe von den Simulationsprüfung von It-Pruefung können Sie ganz schnell die SAP C-THR97-2411 Prüfung 100% bestehen. Es ist doch wert, mit so wenig Zeit und Geld gute Resultate zu bekommen. Schicken Sie doch schnell die Schulungsunterlagen zur SAP C-THR97-2411 Prüfung von It-Pruefung in den Warenkorb.

  31. Mark Evans

    KaoGuTi 是專門給全世界的IT認證的考生提供培訓資料的,購買我們所有的資料能保證考生一次性通過 EUNS20-001 考試,讓考生信心百倍的通過 EUNS20-001 考試認證,給自己的職業生涯帶來重大影響,用自己專業的頭腦和豐富的考試經驗來滿足考生們的需求。本題庫網用超低的價格和高品質的 Esri EUNS20-001 考古題真試題和答案來奉獻給廣大考生。

  32. Will Bell

    Thank you for your article, it was incredibly enlightening. I advanced in my career with this Valid exam NCP-MCI-6.10 simulator fee, and now it’s free for everyone. May you all achieve your promotions soon!

  33. Tom Taylor

    AZ-305試験トレントの3つのバージョンを提供しており、PDFバージョン、PCバージョン、APPオンラインバージョンが含まれています。各バージョンの機能と使用方法は異なり、実際の状況に適した最も便利なバージョンを選択できます。たとえば、PDFバージョンは、AZ-305テストトレントをダウンロードして印刷するのに便利で、学習の閲覧に適しています。 PDFバージョンを使用している場合は、ペーパーで急流AZ-305ガイドを印刷できます。 AZ-305試験問題のPCバージョンは、Designing Microsoft Azure Infrastructure Solutions実際の試験環境を刺激します。

  34. Carl Green

    Mit den Schulungsunterlagen zur SAP P_SAPEA_2023 Zertifizierungsprüfung von ZertPruefung würden Sie eine glänzende Zukunft haben und Erfolg erzielen. Sie werden Sie nicht nur zum Erfolg führen, sondern auch Ihre Fähigkeiten in der IT-Branche effizient entfalten. Sie umfassen zahlreiche Wissensgebiete und können Ihre Kenntnisse verbessern. Wenn Sie noch warten oder zögern, denn Sie wissen nicht, wie man die SAP P_SAPEA_2023 Zertifizierungsprüfung bestehen kann, keine Sorge. Die Schulungsunterlagen zur SAP P_SAPEA_2023 Zertifizierungsprüfung von ZertPruefung wird alle Ihren Probleme lösen.

  35. Noah Murphy

    I’m absolutely sold on this content, liking it now. The Passing MB-220 score feedback materials are amazing, and I hope they benefit you for free.

  36. Ian Shaw

    Your article was so impressive, I’m truly thankful for it. Enhance your IT expertise and download Valid test AZ-204 questions answers for free. Good luck to all!

  37. Jacob Reed

    여러분은 아직도Fortinet NSE6_WCS-7.0인증시험의 난이도에 대하여 고민 중입니까? 아직도Fortinet NSE6_WCS-7.0시험 때문에 밤잠도 제대로 이루지 못하면서 시험공부를 하고 있습니까? 빨리빨리DumpTOP를 선택하여 주세요. 그럼 빠른 시일내에 많은 공을 들이지 않고 여러분으 꿈을 이룰수 있습니다.

Post a comment

You may use the following HTML:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>