Paul Romer’s Charter Cities: Bold Vision or Neo-Colonial Nightmare?
First published on The Dialog.
A few days ago the World Bank announced that its new Chief Economist, taking over from Kaushik Basu, would be New York University based Paul Romer. Given Romer’s controversial ideas for developing countries, such as “charter cities,” the topic of this essay, and the fact that once again an American has been appointed after two developing countries economists (Justin Lin and Basu), his appointment has elicited surprisingly few critical comments.
Romer is a “star” whose name is synonymous with the theory of Endogenous Growth, a theory that tries to explain the role of knowledge and ideas in causing economic growth.
Traditionally (until the 1950s) economists emphasized the role of capital accumulation (increase in stock of machines and physical structures) in causing growth. In the 1950s researchers like Robert Solow produced models showing that accumulation of machines and physical infrastructure could only go so far in explaining why economic growth happens. There was always a large unexplained portion, the so-called “Solow residual.” This was usually attributed to technological progress that increased the productivity of labour. Romer’s contribution, in the late 1980s was to make a growth model that “endogenized” technological change rather than leaving it exogenous or outside model as it had been so far.
After making a name for himself in growth theory, in the early 2000s Romer left academia to develop an online teaching tool called Aplia. A few years later (2009-10) he was back in the news as far as developing countries are concerned, with his idea of charter cities, sold as a bold new concept in urbanization and development. Now that he has been appointed at the World Bank many are expecting charter cities to come back on the development agenda. Mint and The Economist have already suggested this, approvingly. But charter cities are a disastrous idea. And here is why.
First, what are charter cities? In a nutshell these are enormous special economic zones containing an entire city. Instead of an SEZ dedicated to a few industries or sectors, an empty piece of land in a developing country is developed as a city from scratch, under a “charter” or a set of rules decided in advance. However, since SEZs have gotten a bad name for giving large concessions to corporations, Romer is careful to say that “the goal of a Charter City is reform, not giving out concessions, so in this sense, the motivation for a Charter City is totally different from the motivation behind most special zones.”
Romer’s vision, hundreds of charter cities across the developing world, housing and employing millions, in functioning, well-run environments, is bold and alluring indeed. As we are all only too aware Third World cities suffer from severe lack of infrastructure relative to demand and crisis of public goods such as transport, health, and education as well as a general governance deficit. They are usually mismanaged and prone to severe corruption. Since poor countries cannot govern their cities and cannot create conditions where new migrants want to live in them, these migrants, if they can afford it, migrate to richer countries for work and for building a new life, giving rise the to immigration challenge in the rich countries. Finally, new projects invariably run afoul of resistance from those who stand to be affect negatively. All these problems are side-stepped in a startup charter city. In Romer’s words:
I think what is unusual about a Startup City, as opposed to an existing city, is that you can propose something new without having to go through a long process of consultation and agreement amongst the people that might be affected by a change…With a Startup City, you can propose something entirely new and let people choose whether they want to live under its rules…People who want to try the reform can go there, and people who don’t, they don’t have to.
Romer’s favorite examples are Hong Kong and Singapore followed by Shenzhen, the Chinese city that Deng Xiaoping established to mimic Hong Kong.
To an extent, this idea comes out of Romer’s work on endogenous growth theory. Romer has written, that more and more “emphasis is shifting to the notion that it is ideas, not objects, that poor countries lack.” So here, finally, is Romer’s insight. If Third World citizens are voting with their feet when they can, and choosing to live in First World cities rather than their own, why not get First World governments to come to poor countries and run their cities for them? In Romer’s view, poor countries lack the ideas necessary to run a city well. So to take his example, the Cuban government can go to the Canadian government and ask it to start and run a new city in Cuba. If Third World governments were willing, such charter cities could come up all across the developing world. None of the existing laws in a poor country would apply to these spaces. They would be run according to the rules of the charter agreed on in advance by the governments in question.
Not surprisingly, when he first floated this idea Romer was severely criticized and accused of neo-colonialism. In addition, there is also the danger of “misinterpretation” by corrupt governments resulting in corporate takeover. Romer’s proposal has already been misused in Honduras where the concept was taken in the direction of a “company town” where the “investing company write(s) the laws that govern the territory, establish the local government, hire a private police force, and even has the right to set the educational system and collect taxes.”
The response to the allegation of colonialism redux was that this was purely an “emotional” reaction and that sound rational thinking would show the virtue in such an approach to urbanization in the Third World. The problems with ceding sovereignty over a city to a foreign government are, I think, obvious to anyone with a sense of history. But apart from such “emotive” arguments, there are other even more fundamental reasons as to why this is a bad idea.
By its nature the charter city is an exclusive, enclave space. True, Romer repeatedly emphasizes the voluntary nature of the concept. People choose to move into a charter city knowing fully well that they will have little say in how it is run. They are not being coerced into living in a city, they are choosing to live in it. Even accepting this argument at face value, the charter will contain rules of migration into the city. Effectively this brings the problem, of immigration facing Europe and America right now within our own borders. Within Indian border the government of Canada or the United States will decide who gets to live inside the city. Perhaps one reason that charter cities are attractive to some is that they will reduce immigration pressure on developed countries. But at the cost of reproducing those problems within developing countries, since a charter city takes care of none of the structural problems plaguing the global economy (such as lack of adequate jobs where people already live).
But the real bankruptcy of the idea is that it suffers from the same “failure of the imagination” that Romer says plagues urban policy. It can only imagine one institutional solution to the problem of urban living, viz. that developed over the past two hundred years in Europe and America. In place of the badly managed copies that we currently have, it promises a well-run copy. Evidence is gathering by the day that the Euro-American city is ecologically unsustainable. It relies on large resources and sinks, freely externalizing its costs to more disadvantaged parts of the world. China has been moving rapidly along this unsustainable path, but India does not have to mimic Europe, America and China.
Our ecological footprint is still low. Of course this is mainly due high levels of poverty and accompanying low consumption. But as more and more cities in Europe and elsewhere move to bicycles, local economies, and low production-low consumption “artisanal” lifestyles, space is opening for imaging alternative urban futures. Instead of moving through the phase of mass automobiles only to arrive at bicycles (as Northern European cities have done), we can chart our own path, bypassing the automobiles stage entirely, if only we have the imagination and the will. We also have a repository of ideas and wisdom that takes sustainability seriously. We have had thinkers such as Gandhi who recognized the problems of indiscriminate urbanization and offered alternatives. It is up to us to take these ideas into the 21st century and offer the world a genuine alternative to the crisis created by Europe and America.
Make no mistake, the urbanisation challenge in India, as in other developing countries, is large and unprecedented in scale in social, economic, political and ecological terms. Over the next few decades more than half the world will be urban. More people will live in cities than at any point in human history. If we want our cities to be socially inclusive, economically equal, political democratic, and ecologically sustainable we have a very large task on our collective hands. We will need all the ideas we can get to meet this challenge. But solutions such as charter cities that only mask “business as usual” under new names do not rise up to the challenge.
exam bank
such an interesting article here.I was searching for something like that for quite a long time and at last I have found it here.
Thank you! Very interesting.
Pamper yourself with premium beauty services at Swan Skin & body solutions. With over 20 years of experience, we provide quality services that rejuvenate your mind and body. Our licensed therapists and trained professionals provide the most high-end, personalized, and top-notch best beauty salons in Melbournesuburb.
lingerie for large breasts
mycamtv thanks for this informational post
I am totally Agree with you
This is very informative
Thanks for posting this useful information.
Visit Accounting Test Bank!
I am totally Agree with you
This is very informative
Thanks for posting this useful information.
Visit Nursing Test Bank!
Thanks for sharing,
We discuss about Listing sites in the UK are invaluable resources for anyone looking to buy, sell, rent, or explore properties, products, or services. These platforms offer a vast array of listings, ranging from real estate and vehicles to job opportunities and local businesses.
當你嘗試了我們提供的關於Salesforce Nonprofit-Cloud-Consultant認證考試的部分考題及答案,你可以對我們PDFExamDumps做出選擇了，我們會100%為你提供方便以及保障。請記住能讓你100%通過Salesforce Nonprofit-Cloud-Consultant認證考試的就是我們的PDFExamDumps。
I can’t thank you enough for your article, it really opened my mind. Sharing the C1000-172 valid dumps pdf test that was a key factor in my promotion and salary increase. It’s free for you today—hope you achieve your professional dreams!
Thank you for sharing; it was truly incredible! I’m offering the ADM-201 official practice test test that helped me advance in my career with a promotion and raise. It’s available for free today. I hope you succeed in your career!
I’m in awe of your insights, thank you for sharing your article! Get the Updated CISA CBT questions for free—your promotion and salary increase start now!
I really appreciate your work, it left a profound impact on me. This is the Latest 300-610 study guide book test that helped me secure my promotion and pay raise, now shared with you at no cost. Hope you succeed in your career!
I’m all in for this content—instant like. Here are the AD0-E908 exam online materials, free of charge—best of luck!
時間とお金の集まりより正しい方法がもっと大切です。Identity-and-Access-Management-Designer-JPN試験のために勉強していますなら、我々の提供するIdentity-and-Access-Management-Designer-JPN試験ソフトはあなたの選びの最高です。信じられないなら、デモをご覧ください。我々も返金保障があります。180日以内、お客様はIdentity-and-Access-Management-Designer-JPN試験に失敗したら、我々はお客様の支払った金額をお客様に戻り返すことができます。
Thank you for your article, it gave me such a fresh perspective. Free Reliable 1D0-622 test collection free exam resources are available now—good luck!
Instant like for this incredible content. Best of luck! Here’s the free New NSE5_FMG-7.2 test simulator fee material to help you.
Truly an impressive article, I’m grateful for your share. The Valid AZ-204 test vce resources are excellent, and they’re available to you free of charge.
Thank you for your article, it was incredibly thought-provoking. Get your hands on the PSE-PrismaCloud Online training materials questions for free—the key to your next promotion!
It was incredibly enriching. Elevate your IT abilities with free HQT-4420 latest exam dumps free. Best wishes for success!
I appreciate you sharing this brilliant article, it’s really fantastic! I’m about to take the Latest CTFL4 test format exam. Wishing for a great result!
This article is absolutely amazing, thank you for sharing! I achieved a promotion and salary increase with the help of this Valid SPLK-1003 test duration. Now it’s free for everyone. Best wishes for your own career growth!
Your article was truly enlightening and inspiring, thank you! Here’s the free DASM reliable test camp sheet material! Wishing everyone good luck on their exams!
This article gave me a new perspective, thank you for sharing! Sharing New ASIS-PCI exam practice exam questions for free—promotions and salary growth await!
Wenn Sie Ihre Position in der konkurrenzfähigen Gesellschaft durch die Oracle 1z0-1066-24 Zertifizierungsprüfung festigen und Ihre fachliche Fähigkeiten verbessern wollen, müssen Sie gute Fachkenntnisse besitzen und sich viel Mühe für die Prüfung geben. Aber es ist nicht so einfach, die Oracle 1z0-1066-24 Zertifizierungsprüfung zu bestehen. Vielleicht durch die Oracle 1z0-1066-24 Zertifizierungsprüfung können Sie Ihnen der IT-Branche vorstellen. Aber man braucht nicht unbedingt viel Zeit und Energie, die Fachkenntnisse kennenzulernen. Sie können die Schulungsunterlagen zur Oracle 1z0-1066-24 Zertifizierungsprüfung von ZertSoft wählen. Sie werden zielgerichtet nach den IT-Zertifizierungsprüfungen entwickelt. Mit ihr können Sie mühelos die schwierige Oracle 1z0-1066-24 Zertifizierungsprüfung bestehen.
Your article was truly inspiring, thank you for sharing it with me. I owe my career success to the C_S4CPB_2408 sure pass test, and now I’m sharing it with you free of charge!
I’m really inspired by this article, thank you for sharing it! Using this Valid H13-624_V5.5 test vce, I earned a promotion and raise. Now, it’s free for everyone. Best of luck in your career growth!
Your article is fantastic, I really appreciate you sharing it! The Latest CTS-I test cram materials are excellent, and they’re totally free.
Thank you for your article; it was truly stunning! This is the Reliable CSCM-001 practice questions free test that helped me achieve a promotion and raise. It’s available to you for free today, and I wish you success in reaching your career goals.
Your article is incredibly inspiring, thank you for sharing! The Latest H19-319_V2.0 test sample material is superb, and you don’t have to pay anything for it.
This article gave me new motivation, thank you for sharing! Here’s the A00-215 latest exam camp free test that got me promoted and raised. Today, it’s free for everyone! Hope you achieve your professional goals!
지금 같은 경쟁력이 심각한 상황에서Lpi 306-300시험자격증만 소지한다면 연봉상승 등 일상생활에서 많은 도움이 될 것입니다.Lpi 306-300시험자격증 소지자들의 연봉은 당연히Lpi 306-300시험자격증이 없는 분들보다 높습니다. 하지만 문제는Lpi 306-300시험패스하기가 너무 힘듭니다. DumpTOP는 여러분의 연봉상승을 도와 드리겠습니다.
Thank you for sharing such a motivational article! Sharing the Reliable exam C_S4CPB_2408 topics pdf exam that got me my promotion and salary raise—it’s free for all today. Hope you all achieve your professional dreams!
After reading this article, my thinking is clearer, and I have gained a lot. Here’s the New test CQE collection free test that led to my promotion and salary raise. It’s available for free today for all—wishing you success in your career!
The article was full of valuable insights. Free TDVAN5 practice test exam has great content, and it’s provided to you without any fees.
Thank you for keeping this platform relevant and up-to-date. หวย ฮานอย ruay
Through this article, I gained a lot of useful information. Best wishes to everyone! CCSP latest exam camp sheet test questions are now available for free.
This article has helped me understand many complex concepts, and I’ve gained a lot. Here’s the COBIT-2019 valid exam collection free test I passed to earn my promotion and salary increase. It’s free for you today—best of luck in your career goals!
This article is fantastic, thank you for sharing this insight. Elevate your IT skills and download free PMI-RMP test dumps pdf. Wishing you all the best!
This content is exceptional—clicking like now. The DVA-C02 valid exam camp exam questions are shared for free. Wishing you the best in your exams!
I was deeply moved by the article. This is the C-S4CS-2408 Pdf braindumps exam that helped me get ahead with a promotion and raise. It’s free today—wishing you success in your career!
It was a real eye-opener. The DA0-001 exam demo test that helped me earn a promotion and salary raise is free for you today. Best of luck reaching your career goals!
あなたはすぐCFE試験に参加したいかもしれません。そうすれば、自分の能力を有る分野で証明できます。しかし、CFE試験のために、どんな資料がいいですか。もちろん、CFE問題集は一番いいです。CFE問題集の内容は精確で、全面的です。CFE問題集について、私たちはあなたのお問い合わせをお待ちします。
Thank you for your article; it really opened my eyes. It’s almost time for the New free study SPLK-1005 questions exam! Wish me success!
I’m deeply thankful for your article, it really stood out to me. The Latest test H13-527_V5.0 questions answers exam is coming up fast. Wish me the best!
Such a powerful article, thank you for sharing! Here are the free SAVIGA-C01 exam questions vce materials! Best of luck on your test.
Thank you for sharing your article, it’s truly amazing! Free H13-511_V5.5 valid test sims shared for enhancing your IT skills. Wishing you success in your journey!
This article has given me a new understanding of this field, and it’s truly inspiring. The C-THR88-2405 reliable test collection sheet content is fantastic, and you can access it freely.
What a brilliant piece of writing, thank you for sharing it. Free access to the C-SIGDA-2403 practice questions questions—your path to promotion and salary increase!
The article gave me so many new ideas. The Reliable C_STC_2405 test questions content is top-tier, and it’s totally free.
I’m so grateful for your article, it was truly eye-catching and insightful. The GRCP valid exam collection free exam questions are available for free—your ticket to a promotion and salary increase!
当社Jpshikenは、優れた職人技と成熟したサービスシステムを備えた専門家グループを作り上げました。 Okta-Certified-Consultantの最新の質問の品質は高いです。なぜなら、私たちの専門家チームが実際の試験のニーズに応じてそれらを整理および編集し、試験に関するすべての情報の本質を抽出したからです。したがって、当社のOkta-Certified-Consultant認定ツールは、同種の学習教材の中でもブティックです。高品質のOkta-Certified-Consultant試験準備のための熱心な追求により、最高ランクのOkta-Certified-Consultantテストガイドが作成され、販売量が常に増加しています。
This is amazing content, I’m giving it a like. Enhance your IT knowledge—free Reliable FC0-U61 real test question shared! Wishing you success!
After reading this article, I have a more thorough understanding of the related topics. The SPLK-1003 Free Dumps exam is coming soon. Fingers crossed for success!
Per Pass4Test können Sie die neuesten Fragen und Antworten zur EXIN CDCS Zertifizierungsprüfung bekommen. Bitte kaufen Sie die Produkte schnell, so dass Sie die Prüfung zum ersten mal bestehen können. Zur Zeit besitzt nur PassTest die kürzlich aktualisierten EXIN CDCS Prüfungsfragen und Antworten .
Your site is a fantastic source of knowledge thank you! สมัคร แทง หวย บี
Your article had such an impact on me, thank you for sharing it. I achieved a promotion and salary increase with this 712-50 reliable braindumps free. It’s now available for free to everyone. Best of luck with your promotions!
That article left me speechless. Free access to the HP2-I73 latest exam dumps questions test questions! Wishing you all the best in your exams!
No delay, just liking this awesome content. We offer you access to the rich content of Latest ADM-201 test cost for free, hoping it benefits you.
Your article really stuck with me, I’m sincerely grateful. Latest NetSec-Generalist test voucher test questions are now free. Good luck with your exams!
The depth of research and clarity of presentation in your writing are remarkable.
web cờ bạc online
I’m so appreciative of your article, it really made an impression. Here’s the Test L6M1 study guide test that played a part in my promotion and salary increase, and it’s free for you today! Wishing you all the best in your career!
I’m truly amazed by your article, thank you for your generosity! The C-THR83-2411 free vce dumps materials are here for free. Wishing you good luck!